But the effect of such electoral events on regime stability is disputed. To fill this gap, i use multinomial logit models to simultaneously predict transitions to ea and democracy from non. Although the media in malaysia is largely private, most observers point to the various legislative mechanisms and ownership structures through which compliance is ensured. Table notes constitution 2004, articles, 49, 50in the election of the members of the national assembly of 2005 and that for the election scheduled for january and march 2011, should no candidate obtain an absolute majority a second round was held, unless none of the other candidates obtained 10% of the vote or more, in which case the candidate with more than 10% was declared. The logic of electoral authoritarianism ethiomedia. Abstract studies of electoral authoritarianism in southeast asia highlight the significance of a compliant media in acting as an obstacle to democratization. Table of contents for electoral authoritarianism edited by andreas schedler. Autocracies with multiparty elections have spread across the globe, but we know little about what predicts transitions to electoral authoritarianism ea. Electoral authoritarianism schedler major reference. Electoral authoritarian regimes practice authoritarianism behind the institutional facades of representative democracy.
Drawing partly on huntington 1991, 110 1, geddes distinguishes personalist, military, and singleparty regimes. Although the electoral process may be characterized by largescale abuses of. The interplay between poverty and electoral authoritarianism. Modern democratic regimes all meet four minimum criteria. Under electoral democracy, contests comply with minimal democratic norms.
Authoritarianism has many different approaches for its direct implementation. This article explores the impact of constitutional structures on democratic transitions from electoral authoritarianism. Elites even manipulate the results of the general election to preserve their power snyder, 2006. The politics of authoritarian rule yale university. Building on the formal literature on democratization, this paper models a dictators choice between closed authoritarianism, electoral authoritarianism, and democracy in the shadow of violent revolt. Evidence from postcommunist eurasia ruchan kaya rkaya at ufl dot edu and michael bernhard bernhard at ufl dot edu abstract since the end of the cold war, comparativists have radically reexamined the role that elections play in. Filling in the lacuna, this new book presents cuttingedge research on the internal dynamics of electoral authoritarian regimes. Shirah notes that the attempts of such regimes to retain democratic trappings can be selfdefeating allowing opposition groups to organise, for. Of course, elections are key to defining competitive authoritarian regimes, but the nature of the regime affects other institutions as well, such as the role of courts. Identifying electoral authoritarian regimes in africa in order to assess this question regimes in africa are classified to distinguish electoral autocracies that have transformed into democracies from cases of selfreproducing electoral authoritarianism and cases of such regimes that have broken down. March 20, 20 malaysia is an electoral authoritarian regime, not a democracy by william leong, mp for selayang as political parties gear for the final stretch to the thgeneral elections, malaysians must not forget, our country is not a democracy. After a decade in power and a contested reelection in 2000, president fujimori was removed from office on the ground of moral.
Political scientists have created many typologies describing variations of authoritarian forms of government. Electoral authoritarianism and economic control sage journals. Using an instrumental variables setup, this article shows that electoral authoritarianism ea has a positive causal effect relative to nonelectoral autocracy on a wide range of human development outcomes, including infant mortality, literacy, and gender balance in schooling. Authoritarianism is a form of government characterized by strong central power and limited political freedoms. The collapse of the presidency of alberto fujimori in november 2000 brought an end to one of the most controversial periods in the contemporary political history of peru. In recent years scholarly attention has shifted from the study of democratization to the phenomenon of electoral authoritarianism. Rather than place regimes on a linear continuum from authoritarianism to democracy, it highlights the multi. Theories of democratic politics see elections as the means by which citizens hold politicians accountable for the quality of. Bibliographic record and links to related information available from the library of congress catalog. The origins of electoral authoritarianism and democracy by. This paper appraises the state of the field on hybrid regimes by depicting the tensions and blurred boundaries of democracy and authoritarianism with adjectives. Are elections mechanisms of authoritarian stability or.
The role of legislatures in new democracies and under electoral authoritarianism the main aim of this analysis1 is to show that executives may be held less accountable by their legislatures in new democracies than under electoral authoritarianism. Yet they violate liberaldemocratic minimum standards of freedom, fairness, and integrity in so systematic and profound ways as to render elections instruments of authoritarian rule, rather then instruments of democracy. Project muse the era of electoral authoritarianism. An alternative conceptualization and ordering of regimes are subsequently introduced using a configurative approach. Why do some electoral authoritarian regimes survive for decades while others become democracies. Dominant party authoritarian regimes are relatively narrow in scale, falling under the umbrella of competitive authoritarianism. If the degree of competitiveness were the only dimension along which authoritarian regimes differed, we would need no regime typology. The dynamics of unfree competition by andreas schedler. Why parties and elections in authoritarian regimes. The strategic origins of electoral authoritarianism. Electoral authoritarianism and hybrid regimes are two interchangeable concepts that overarch competitive authoritarianism and hegemonic electoral authoritarianism, two subtypes of electoral authoritarianism. In the heady days after the 2011 uprisings, the military exploited egypts populist uprisings to replace mubaraks business and domestic security elite with a military ruling elite. Electoral authoritarianism and the print media in malaysia. Elections and democratization in authoritarian regimes.
Elections are now used to legitimate authoritarian regimes, not herald liberal democracy. The dynamics of unfree competition andreas schedler, andreas schedler on. In order to further explore and understand contemporary authoritarianism, we must consider the practice of electoral authoritarianism. The era of electoral authoritarianism world politics. Authoritarian regimes may be either autocratic or oligarchic in nature, and may be based upon the rule of a party or the. Poverty and political mobilization in zambia and u ganda wp 2012. I authoritarian system robert bedeski encyclopedia of life support systems eolss 1. In africa, referendums have played a critical role in advancing electoral authoritarianism, in particular by extending presidential terms and eliminating term limits. This paper deals with the general question of how to allocate resources across the set. I describe the mechanisms of stealth authoritarianism in the next part, but the concept can be articulated here briefly. Electoral authoritarianism is a complex political phenomenon embedded in normative presuppositions that underlie the idea of democratic elections. Way 53 competitive authoritarianism must be distinguished from democracy on the one hand and fullscale authoritarianism on the other. Malaysia is an electoral authoritarian regime, not a. Taking electoral institutions under authoritarianism seriously, this research analyzes the effects of variations in electoral rules on voter behavior, parliamentarian clientelistic service provision, and ethnicallybased citizenstate linkages.
In these regimes, regular elections are held for national legislatures and chief executives, yet they fail to live up to democratic standards of freedom and fairness. This introductory chapter addresses three analytical core issues with which the emergent comparative study of electoral authoritarian regimes is grappling. At present, most authoritarian regimes hold some sort of elections. Instead, a continuous measure of competitiveness which would serve. The empirical chapters 412 focus on the conflictive interaction between rulers and opposition parties in the central arena of struggle under electoral authoritarianism. The good thing is that scaring off specters is an easy assignment, 3 in particular for those who fail to believe in scary metaphysical creatures. Pdf on may 1, 2016, marco bunte and others published the end of militaryguided electoral authoritarianism. Unesco eolss sample chapters government and politics vol.
Although in historical perspective the authori tarian use of elections is nothing new, contemporary electoral authoritarian regimes take the timehonored practice of. Aziz and others published military electoral authoritarianism in egypt find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. If one placed postcommunist russia on the world map of political regimes, it would fit into the category of electoral or competitive authoritarianism. The logic of electoral authoritarianism, a schedler doc. Electoral authoritarianism in the third wave of democratization. The methodological chapters discuss issues of conceptualization and measurement in fresh and innovate ways. Under autocracy, the dictator controls policy but lacks information on the policy demands of citizens and thus the likelihood of popular revolt. In competitive authoritarian regimes, by contrast, elections are often bitterly fought. Electoral authoritarian regimes hold regular multiparty elections for parliament and the chief executive.
Although growing at a fast pace, contemporary scholarship on dictatorships. We argue that under electoral authoritarian regimes, parliamentary systems permit dictators to survive longer than they do in presidential systems. Yolande bouka, who studies politics, the dynamics of war, and gender and security in subsaharan africa, will visit washington college on october 3 to speak on the rise and contagion of electoral authoritarianism in east africa. Electoral authoritarianism, according to andreas schedler, is defined as states under the control of a dictator who has successfully established the institutional facades of. They hold regular multiparty elections at the national level, yet violate liberal. Contents data are machine generated based on prepublication provided by the publisher. Pdf beyond electoral authoritarianism researchgate. Full text views reflects the number of pdf downloads, pdfs sent. Electoral authoritarianism characterises regimes that present an illusion of multiparty democracy at the local and national levels while effectively stripping elections of efficacy. Challenging electoral authoritarianism in malaysia. The strategic origins of electoral authoritarianism volume 50 issue 1 michael k. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. The result known in advance, elections can be held frequently.
As a result of these differences, authoritarian elections range from the relatively free and fair to those in which candidates and citizens choices are more. It is the nature of these contests that divides electoral authoritarianism from closed authoritarianism. Stealth authoritarianism refers to the use of legal mechanisms that exist in regimes with favorable democratic credentials for antidemocratic ends. The era of electoral authoritarianism project muse johns. Introduction authoritarianism is a theory and a system of government customarily linked with. An electoral authoritarian regime an electoral authoritarian regime is one that uses. The era of electoral authoritarianism volume 64 issue 1 yonatan l. Are elections mechanisms of authoritarian stability or democratization. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Ethnicity, electoral institutions, and clientelism.
In electoral authoritarian ea regimes, multiple parties compete for positions of national state power in regular elections that transgress democratic minimum. Electoral authoritarian regimes the distinction between electoral authoritarianism and democracy hinges on the quality of electoral competition diamond 2002. Although parties and elections are thought of as defining features of democracy, most authoritarian governments also rely on political parties and hold elections. Transitions from electoral authoritarianism repositorio cide. Today, electoral authoritarianism represents the most common form of political regime in the developing world and the one we know least about. Pdf electoral authoritarianism and economic control.
135 646 230 434 616 925 1419 120 538 1170 352 264 931 1290 290 881 534 740 1496 337 1244 861 829 243 182 974 1139 724 424 1211 877 159 289 865 328 1416 390 890